About Us
Who We Are
Cream of the Crop is a small town ice cream shop serving locally made soft serve and premium hand-dipped ice cream in the heart of Wakeman, Ohio. Founded in May 2020 by Keely Krumwiede, an elementary school teacher whose idea of a dream retirement is working her first job again as an ice cream scooper.
Come Find Us
It's easy! Turn south at the light and it's just one block down on the right (next to the barber shop). Our address is
18 Pleasant St. Wakeman, OH 44889.
Our Ice Cream
We proudly serve Nuhfer premium hand dipped ice cream and the best Toft's soft serve. It's the creamiest, most delicious ice cream you can find. Trust us, we've eaten a lot.
Menu
Soft Serve
Vanilla, Chocolate & Swirl
Hand Dipped
Current Flavors: Butter Pecan, Mint Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel Praline, Reese's Lovers, Apple, Wild Cherry Cheesecake, Apple, Rainbow Sherbet, Egg Nog, Hot Cocoa, Peppermint Stick, Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl (LF, NAS) & Cherry Cordial (LF, NAS)
Cone Upgrades
Sugar cone, waffle cone, chocolate dip & crunch coat
Sundaes
Choose Your Flavor: Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Strawberry, Red Raspberry, Creme de Menthe, Chocolate, Butterscotch, Pineapple, Peach, Caramel, Marshmallow, Cherry or Blueberry
Specialty Sundaes
Choose Your Sundae: Turtle, Butter Pecan, Fluffer Nutter, HF Brownie Bites, HF Cookie Dough, Mint Oreo, Reese's Lovers or Pineapple Coconut or Banana Split
Milkshakes & Malts
Flavors: Chocolate, Cherry, Peanut Butter, Vanilla, Pineapple, Mint, Strawberry, Banana & Marshmallow
Flusters
Varieties: Reese's Cup, Reese's Pieces, M&M, Oreo, Heath, Brownie, Cookie Dough, Nerds, Mint Oreo, Turtle, Chocolate Covered Strawberry, Chocolate Covered Cherry, Banana Fluffer Nutter, Chocolate Covered Banana & Pineapple Coconut
Floats
Classic root beer or your favorite soda
Ice Cream Cakes
Traditional and specialty ice cream cakes made to order with our delicious quality ice cream and ingredients right in our shop!
Snacks
Nachos, big beef hot dogs, chili cheese dogs, chips & popcorn
Drinks
Pop (cans or bottles) & water
Contact Us
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
18 Pleasant Street, Wakeman, Ohio 44889, United States
Hours
We are closed for winter but you can still order ice cream cakes any day of the week. See our custom cake order form at the top of the page.
Copyright © 2020 Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop - All Rights Reserved.