WELCOME
Our Ice Cream
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream is premium small batch ice cream, made using a 15% butterfat mix for the highest quality, creamiest taste. We also serve Toft's premium soft serve and dairy-free Dole soft serve.
Now you can take your favorite flavors home in Cream of the Crop pints, quarts or half gallons, available in many of our 20+ flavors.
Learn more About Us!
FLAVORS
Contact Us
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
18 Pleasant Street, Wakeman, Ohio 44889, United States
Special Orders
Call or email us for ice cream cake and cow pie custom orders or fill out the form on our site.